Just some notes on mystery white boy, the Valley novella. Trying to wrap up the ending.
Martin goes to the diner after Gabriel knocks Joel's teeth out, and Gabriel and Davíd show up. The question- why, and why together? What gets them talking, what brings this to its conclusion? How does this help Martin change?
They go because that's where they go, it's the Valley and there's not many other options. And maybe they want to see Martin, sure. Actually- scratch that, the plural there. They go for different reasons, because they have different circumstances. Davíd goes because he wants to see Martin, because things with Monica didn't go as planned and he needs some dude-time. Gabriel goes because he wants to ask Martin if his ideas were stupid all along, if that's why Martin never took them seriously. They show up at the same time because the show just ended, and they're both driving at roughly the same speed from the same point of origin to the same destination.
And they get talking because Gabriel starts talking. He doesn't need to be drawn out, not really, he just has to decide to start.
So the real question is- in what way does Martin change?
At the beginning of the book, he's shallow and aloof and trying his best to act like he's a character in some story. At the end of the book, he's explaining how he's not the things he might have become. How does he not end up shallow and aloof?
It's not going to be anything dramatic. This is a story that must end with an anti-climax, because it's not his story. Gabriel's story is dramatic and sweeping, but since Martin is the narrator, its affect on him has to be more subtle. So what happens to Martin, specifically, after this night?
He starts playing music, instead of not playing music. But there's hardly any mention of him as a musician earlier in the book, so that needs to be fixed. How does he feel about the fact that everyone else is a musician and he's not playing music? Is he jealous? Why doesn't he play? And when he does, why does he go the solo route? Why doesn't he start a band?
The answer is that he's saving himself, though for what no one can tell. He didn't play because he was scared of being another asshole playing music, and he lacked the confidence to actually start (so much of Martin's problems are due to a lack of confidence). He plays at being aloof because it means he can't be rejected.
Gabriel was aloof because it meant people might listen to him. He was trying to be a symbol, and the less he was involved in petty human drama, the more symbolic a figure he could be. Martin wanted some of that power, the benefit of being mythic, although he wanted it to his own ends- rather than be amorphous and mythic because it meant people would follow him, he wanted it because he wanted them to see him as something bigger than he saw himself. The more he was a vague outline, the more likely they were to fill him in with details that made him more interesting. It's why he didn't want anyone to know about Yvette. Not playing his music was another way to keep his distance. They would sound better if no one ever heard them.
In fact, that's interesting enough to be a point worth making early on.
So he starts playing music, but he doesn't become another Valley dude in a band, either. Why not? He's not one of the special ones.
Gabriel isn't, but he becomes special because he leaves. Davíd does the same thing, albeit more slowly and more roundabout. Martin needs to leave, too. But where and why?
He might have been paralyzed and insincere, but he's not. He might have been another Valley dude with faux-ambition, but he's not. He might have been caught up in girls and drama and lost years to it, but he's not.
How does this night explain why that's the case?
Mostly it has to be Gabriel. He has to be inspired by Gabriel. At the very least, he has to be inspired to play music. Watching Gabriel shed his distance and become a real boy, Martin feels like he has to do the same. He doesn't fall into the Valley's traps because he figures out why they're traps, he knew that before anyone else did. He could stay forever, or he could go right away. He knows that he can't change things there, that he can't make it into a new place just by wishing. He knows he can't even change the people. He plays solo because he doesn't want to rely on anyone.
When he says this is a list of the things that I might have been, but I'm not, he's talking specifically about Ric, about Davíd, and about Gabriel. Ric is the guy who falls into the Valley traps. Davíd is the guy who loses heart because he's seeking drama. Gabriel is the guy who inspires others but doesn't accomplish much himself. Martin goes further and faster than any of the others because he knew them. And that's the point.
Martin goes to the diner after Gabriel knocks Joel's teeth out, and Gabriel and Davíd show up. The question- why, and why together? What gets them talking, what brings this to its conclusion? How does this help Martin change?
They go because that's where they go, it's the Valley and there's not many other options. And maybe they want to see Martin, sure. Actually- scratch that, the plural there. They go for different reasons, because they have different circumstances. Davíd goes because he wants to see Martin, because things with Monica didn't go as planned and he needs some dude-time. Gabriel goes because he wants to ask Martin if his ideas were stupid all along, if that's why Martin never took them seriously. They show up at the same time because the show just ended, and they're both driving at roughly the same speed from the same point of origin to the same destination.
And they get talking because Gabriel starts talking. He doesn't need to be drawn out, not really, he just has to decide to start.
So the real question is- in what way does Martin change?
At the beginning of the book, he's shallow and aloof and trying his best to act like he's a character in some story. At the end of the book, he's explaining how he's not the things he might have become. How does he not end up shallow and aloof?
It's not going to be anything dramatic. This is a story that must end with an anti-climax, because it's not his story. Gabriel's story is dramatic and sweeping, but since Martin is the narrator, its affect on him has to be more subtle. So what happens to Martin, specifically, after this night?
He starts playing music, instead of not playing music. But there's hardly any mention of him as a musician earlier in the book, so that needs to be fixed. How does he feel about the fact that everyone else is a musician and he's not playing music? Is he jealous? Why doesn't he play? And when he does, why does he go the solo route? Why doesn't he start a band?
The answer is that he's saving himself, though for what no one can tell. He didn't play because he was scared of being another asshole playing music, and he lacked the confidence to actually start (so much of Martin's problems are due to a lack of confidence). He plays at being aloof because it means he can't be rejected.
Gabriel was aloof because it meant people might listen to him. He was trying to be a symbol, and the less he was involved in petty human drama, the more symbolic a figure he could be. Martin wanted some of that power, the benefit of being mythic, although he wanted it to his own ends- rather than be amorphous and mythic because it meant people would follow him, he wanted it because he wanted them to see him as something bigger than he saw himself. The more he was a vague outline, the more likely they were to fill him in with details that made him more interesting. It's why he didn't want anyone to know about Yvette. Not playing his music was another way to keep his distance. They would sound better if no one ever heard them.
In fact, that's interesting enough to be a point worth making early on.
So he starts playing music, but he doesn't become another Valley dude in a band, either. Why not? He's not one of the special ones.
Gabriel isn't, but he becomes special because he leaves. Davíd does the same thing, albeit more slowly and more roundabout. Martin needs to leave, too. But where and why?
He might have been paralyzed and insincere, but he's not. He might have been another Valley dude with faux-ambition, but he's not. He might have been caught up in girls and drama and lost years to it, but he's not.
How does this night explain why that's the case?
Mostly it has to be Gabriel. He has to be inspired by Gabriel. At the very least, he has to be inspired to play music. Watching Gabriel shed his distance and become a real boy, Martin feels like he has to do the same. He doesn't fall into the Valley's traps because he figures out why they're traps, he knew that before anyone else did. He could stay forever, or he could go right away. He knows that he can't change things there, that he can't make it into a new place just by wishing. He knows he can't even change the people. He plays solo because he doesn't want to rely on anyone.
When he says this is a list of the things that I might have been, but I'm not, he's talking specifically about Ric, about Davíd, and about Gabriel. Ric is the guy who falls into the Valley traps. Davíd is the guy who loses heart because he's seeking drama. Gabriel is the guy who inspires others but doesn't accomplish much himself. Martin goes further and faster than any of the others because he knew them. And that's the point.
Leave a comment
